Before working out how much to travel or which Club to join, answer this honestly: are you willing to have a vetted fellow Club member stay in your Home while you're away? If not, home swapping isn't for you. That's a genuine hard stop, not a detail to work around. Everything else in this guide assumes the answer is yes.
Home swapping isn't some new idea chasing Airbnb's success. It predates it by 50+ years. Organised home swapping dates to 1953, when teachers in Switzerland, the Netherlands, and New York independently founded what became Intervac and HomeLink. Airbnb didn't arrive until 2008. This is the older idea, not the newer one.
The same Home often shows up on a Home Swap Club and a short-term rental site at the same time: same walls, same view, same address. On Airbnb, that Home is transactional. You, the guest, are creating revenue for the Home owner and for Airbnb itself, at a cost that keeps climbing. On a Home Swap Club, it's reciprocal: you host as well as stay, and no one is the customer.
Home swapping spans a huge range of Homes, from studios to multi-million dollar houses. Different Clubs lean toward different mixes: some skew everyday, some skew exceptional. The Home Swap Guy names each size Species after the sea creature it matches, from a lone White Whale (nobody's gotten there yet) to Plankton (small, plentiful, where a lot of the energy actually starts):
| Species | Number of Members | Description |
|---|---|---|
| White Whale | 1,000,000+ | No Club has reached this yet. The aspiration point for scale and reach. |
| Dolphins | 100,000+ | Fast growing, global reach. Includes HomeExchange, Kindred. |
| Turtles | 10,000+ | Well established, strong communities. Includes HomeLink, ThirdHome, Intervac, People Like Us. |
| Minnows | 1,000+ | Niche focus, flexible and specialised. Includes Behomm, Swaphouse, HomeSwap.com, FamilyHomeSwaps.com. Often growing fast, and likely won't be Minnows for long. |
| Plankton | Under 1,000 | The smallest, most experimental communities. The foundation the rest grows from. |
Home swapping started long before Airbnb, but until recently stayed more of a niche, hobbyist option. That's changing: major Clubs like HomeExchange and Kindred have each grown past 300,000 members, real momentum behind the Third Wave.
Investors are pouring $100M+ into Home Swapping, recognising it as a growing alternative to high-priced Hotels and Airbnb.
Even the Ultra-Wealthy are getting into Home Swapping. Yep, they like to save money too. A handful of Clubs now offer exclusive access to $5–$20M+ Homes. Spectacular to see, but be realistic about who it's for (clue: it's not you). Without a personal invite or owning a $5–$20M+ Home yourself, the 1% isn't going to let you into their Estates and Castles.
That figure alone tends to trigger a healthy dose of skepticism: a "too good to be true" reaction from newcomers, and a fair one to have.
In future newsletters, we'll break down exact savings from real trips: the same trip, priced out via Hotel or Airbnb, side by side with what it actually cost through a Home Swap Club. The Home Swap Guy doesn't travel for anything less than 80% off, on every trip.
This isn't a limited-time deal the way Hotels and Airbnb run them, e.g. 20% off, book now, gone tomorrow. It's simply how Clubs work, every day. And yes, the Clubs still make money. What you actually pay comes down to three broad factors:
The more you travel, the more it compounds. A Club's annual Membership is a fixed cost, so the more trips it's spread across, the lower your effective cost per trip. Frequent swappers often find their Membership pays for itself within a single trip, with every trip after that adding almost pure savings.
For members who travel often, the real value goes beyond paying less for trips already planned. Over years of regular use, savings can run into the tens of thousands of dollars (The Home Swap Guy has already saved over $100K+), and some of that shows up as entirely new trips: exceptional Homes and destinations that would never have even been an option at unaffordable Hotel or Airbnb rates.
Most of what determines whether a trip is safe has nothing to do with which way you're travelling. Destination, environment, and circumstance carry the same risk whether you're booking a hotel, an Airbnb, or swapping into a Home. Home swapping isn't introducing a new category of risk into travel. It's building on decades of established travel-safety practice, not replacing it.
The honest answer: yes, reasonably safe, not risk-free: the same honest answer worth giving for any way of travelling. What's genuinely different is where home swapping sits relative to a hotel or Airbnb, and in several respects, it sits ahead:
What if something goes wrong? Honest answer: home swapping is still maturing, and insurance offerings vary dramatically between Clubs right now. A few different approaches you'll see:
In 100+ trips and hostings, The Home Swap Guy has experienced only one relatively minor incident: its own very interesting article, for later.
The Home Swap Guy is built on 15 years and 100+ trips and hostings across multiple Home Swap Clubs. Recommendations decided on merit.
The Home Swap Guy is listening, learning, and of course Home Swapping, as the Third Wave of Travel rapidly evolves. A major focus is becoming a single, authoritative source of information for the many different Home Swapping communities, one that grows alongside the Third Wave itself.
New questions will keep arising, and Home Swap Clubs will keep evolving: new ones are created every year. The Home Swap Guy will work and engage directly with Home Swapper communities, not just to keep up, but to help shape how Home Swapping evolves to better meet our needs. Every Club needs to prioritise one of the oldest truths in business: listen to your customers. The ones that do will prosper.
If you enjoyed these Home Swapping basics and answers to the most frequent questions, register for future dispatches at thehomeswapguy.com, a detailed Guide to Home Swapping, and ongoing newsletters as the Third Wave keeps evolving.
Or just ask the guy at concierge@thehomeswapguy.com.
Travel More · Fraction of the Cost · Live Like a Local